Complementary use of voting methods and interactive utility. Hybrid mcda methods to integrate multiple ecosystem services in forest management planning. Preference ranking organisation method for enrichment. Pykalainen no static citation data no static citation data cite. Applications of mcdm methods to strategic planning of state owned forests in finland. Kurttila, pesonen, and kangas 2000 pointed out the technical limitations of the swot. These strategic decisions cannot be made at a lower level without risking suboptimization of resources. Strategic planning guidelines has been prepared to assist agencies1 in understanding the strategic planning process. Mcdm methods in strategic planning of forestry on stateowned. Journal of multicriteria decision analysis, 10, 257271. Combining four methods including analytical hierarchy process, preference ranking organization method for.
Mcdm methods are well suited to deal with forest management and planning problems. Multicriteria decision making mcdm in marine protected. The method called preference ranking organisation method for enrichment evaluations promethee was developed by brans 1982, further extended by brans and vincke 1985 and brans and mareschal 1994. Some of the less obvious limitations of the traditional mcdm methods when dealing with the. The proposed methodology integrates the axiomatic fuzzy set afs theory, analytic hierarchy process ahp, and the concept of simple additive weighting saw to evaluate the strategies by strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats swot analysis. The following are techniques that are commonly used to plan a strategy.
Hajkowicz and collins 2007 analysed over 4 papers in the. Jouni pykalainen, a veikko hiltunen, b pekka leskinen c. Thecityis locatedinthenorthpartofdashtekavirbasin,alargedesertlying in the middle of the iranian plateau, with an arid climate. Applications of mcdm methods to strategic planning of. Preference ranking organisation method for enrichment evaluations. The first step of the strategic planning process is to clearly articulate our direction. Hybrid mcda methods to integrate multiple ecosystem services. An international journal, published for the european water resources association ewra, springer. Strategic planning serves as a road map to help an organization or business discover how to get where it wants to go. An expertbased approach to forest road network planning.
Using survival analysis to predict the harvesting of forest. In addition to scenario analysis, several planning tools may be used in different phases of the strategy process. Committing ourselves to the planning process is different than committing ourselves to a plan. Apr 21, 2015 multicriteria decision analysis mcda is a decision aid frequently used in the field of forest management planning. There has been a growth in research studies conducted using mcdm approaches in recent times keefer et al. Department of logistics beykent university istanbulturkey abstract successful strategic decisions provide the appropriate operational actions for the right markets at the correct time. The first step in strategic planning is developing relevant strategies. Improvements in strategic planning practice are likely to come as it is. After addressing the overview of what planning is, the guidelines provide a framework to help an agency to develop its own strategic plan and to define performance measures that emphasize meaningful results. Strategic planning is the process of developing a strategy and planning its execution. Using different electre methods in strategic planning in the. Currently, mathematical programming is widely used in planning of wood production.
Strategic planning strategic planning is more than ensuring your association will remain financially sound and be able to maintain its reservesits projecting where your association expects to be in five, ten, or fifteen yearsand how your association will get there. Research article employment of multi criteria decision. Strategy is a comprehensive program for an action which defines the major directions of an organization and provides guidelines for resources allocation on the course to achieve the longterm goals of the organization. An application of swotahp to develop a strategic planning. Strategic planning elements and mixed methods the elements of the broward strategic plan are discussed below. Mcdm tools have been used in responding to fresh planning challenges. The plan failed, not because we failed to plan but we failed to. Multiple criteria decision support mcds methods are decision analysis tools. Swotahp method, multiple criteria decision making mcdm, tourist destination, strategic planning.
Comparison of compensatory and noncompensatory multi criteria decision making models in water resources strategic management, water resources management. Methods differ in terms of validity, ease of use, and appropriateness to the problem. While term strategic planning can take on many meanings, for this chapter. Authors addresses kangas and kangas, finnish forest research institute. Bearing in mind the above, it is considered that with the application of mcdm methods, many challenges in todays demanding and complex forest management planning can be facilitated and minimized. Beyond that it is somewhat common to create a long term plan that sets targets for the futu.
Uncertainty in multicriteria decisionmaking springerlink. Many plans are simply filed away because of their obsolescence after the first month or so. The first is a vision or mission statement that sets out a relatively lofty and aspirational goal. Martins b a department of natural resources and environmental sciences, university of illinois, urbana, il, usa bforestry research center, forestry department, institute of agronomy, tapada da ajuda, 49017 lisbon, portugal. An appropriate multiple criteria decision making method. Mcdm methods in strategic planning of forestry on state. Mcdm has been used in environmental management bell, 1975. Comparison of compensatory and noncompensatory multi criteria. An improvement of quantitative strategic planning matrix. Strategic plans all tend to look pretty much the same.
Improving renewable energy policy planning and decision. Kangas, kangas and pykalainen outranking methods as tools in strategic. Comparison of compensatory and noncompensatory multi. The components of direction are purpose, values, mission and vision. The decisionmaking analysis of elearning issues often requires the application of specific multiplecriteria decisionmaking mcdm methods.
Strategic planning of hospitals is long term decisions. He indicated that strategy is a plan, a pattern, a position, a perspective and, in a footnote, he indi. Applications and experiences article in journal of multicriteria decision analysis 105. The results showed that fuzzy ahp method was a useful way to deal with the. Metamodeling snap, a multicriteria method for effective. Kangas, kangas and pyk a l a inen outranking methods as tools in strategic natural resources planning each strategy was considered to be a feasible one in the beginning of the planning process.
Application of anp network analysis process method in swot. It is proposed that in the future, mcdm methods could be used to create joint learning and idea exchange between value chain actors, as these are considered necessary for advancing the circular economy. Application of anp network analysis process method in swot model. An improved swot analysis approach for strategic planning. In recognition of the limitations of the traditional mcdm methods, a number of. Analytic hierarchy process electre forest planning mcds methods. Full text of this article is only available in pdf format. In recognition of the limitations of the traditional mcdm methods, a number of authors proposed an alternative paradigm perhaps best described as soft systems methods to address what these authors described as wicked, messy, illstructured or difficult to define problems. Pdf outranking methods as tools in strategic natural. New modelling paradigms in using multicriteria decision analysis for sustainable forest management. An evaluation of multicriteria methods in integrated. Camelia ram, gilberto montibeller and alec morton extending the use of scenario planning and mcda for the evaluation of strategic options article published version refereed original citation. It includes the evaluation of multiple criteria such as the production of timber and nontimber forest products and tangible as well as intangible values of ecosystem services es.
May 11, 2017 jeffreys i 2004 the use of compensatory and noncompensatory multicriteria analysis for smallscale forestry. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. Multipleuse planning of forest resources by using the analytic hierarchy process. Towards new modeling paradigms in using multicriteria. There are studies of multicriteria decision making mcdm methods with speci. Mcdm methods in strategic planning of forestry on stateowned lands in finland. In the multicriteria strategic planning of an organization, management should often be aware of employees resistance to change before making new decisions. Hence, it is beneficial compared to those methods that take a purely financial perspective. Technique for order of preference by similarity to ideal solution topsis method was merged into the quantitative strategic planning matrix qspm to determine the most attractive strategic group. Complementary use of voting methods and interactive.
Jeffreys i 2004 the use of compensatory and noncompensatory multicriteria analysis for smallscale forestry. Beyond that it is somewhat common to create a long term plan that sets targets for the future. Solving a facility location problem by three multi. Resource allocation, strategic planning and projectrisk management. As a conclusion, the use of more than just one mcdm method in a single planning process is seen usually recommendable. Sport marketing outsourcing using swot and ahp models. Mcda basically originated from operations research involving a wide range of methodologies, nevertheless with an amusing rational foundation in other disciplines. An important concept of strategic planning is an understanding that in order for the community to flourish, everyone needs to work to ensure the teams. Without strategic planning, the community will never know where it is goingmuch less know if it ever got there. Strategic planning on elearning requires multicriteria analysis of many aspects of elearning. The following is the second in a series of ten articles describing one, proven and tested process for effective strategic planning. There are many mcdm methods, and firstly, we have to decide which one of those to apply. Outranking methods as tools in strategic natural resources planning. The internal and external factors most important to the future of the enterprise can be summarized by running a strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats swot analysis e.
This paper focuses on the application of a multicriteria analysis methodology the analytical hierarchy process for the locating of a sanitary landfill on the small island of mauritius. Regarding the vagueness and uncertainty of strategic plans selection process, it requires the linguistic extension of mcdm methods for robust decision making. As only preliminary tests have been made so far, the method is bound to evolve further, and new versions will be developed kangas et al. In addition, developing hybrid mcdm methods is regarded as a potential direction for future research.
A roadmap to launch and grow your organization process as important as product perhaps more. While the relationship with the working level determines the qualityof the results, the relationship with the upper. Department of industrial engineering yazd university yazd, iran abstract. For example, in the 6th 5year development plan, it supports strategic planning, economic instruments, and marketbased instruments in the electricity sector with a focus on solar and wind power. Strategic planning is the cornerstone of every commoninterest community. An integrated afsbased swot analysis approach for evaluation. An application of fuzzy numbers in quantitative strategic planning method with mcdm. It has also been tested in strategic natural resource planning in state forestry in finland pesonen et al. University, took the entire strategic planning establishment to task in his book, the rise and fall of strategic planning. An application of swotahp to develop a strategic planning for a tourist destination yeongae jeon nutrition, hospitality, and retailing department. Application of multicriteria decision analysis in environmental decision making. The three types of strategy there are three types of strategic planning that are essential to every firm.
Multicriteria decision analysis in natural resource management. This article outlines the development of a hybrid methodology aimed to help the policymakers in strategic planning. Oct 28, 2015 the strategic planning process in a company is the development of a direction, the taking of decisions and allocating resources necessary to achieve the final goal. In crisp mcdm model, usually utility of alternatives is assumed a real number, however. In effect, mintzberg declared strategy did indeed have several meanings, all of which were useful. A multicriteria model to evaluate strategic plans for the. Another example is the law, which endorses supplying 20% of the electricity consumed from renewable sources.
Strategic planning is now a ubiquitous practice in u. Site selection of sanitary landfills on the small island. Adapting modern strategic decision support tools in the. Complementary use of voting methods and interactive utility analysis in participatory strategic forest planning. Alternative methods also can yield strikingly different rankings of. Multicriteria decision making mcdm is a general approach that has been applied to a wide range of natural resource management situations.
Strategic planning, oopp method, problem tree, objective tree introduction. To resolve this shortcoming, kurttila, pesonen, kangas. Also, li, ang, and gay 1997, proposed a neural networks application, which consists of scenario generation for strategic business planning. Sport marketing outsourcing using swot and ahp models davood gharakhani 1.
Applications and experiences the forests in finland have been under intensive planning for decades. While the conventional qspm has proven to be a useful tool for strategic planning in several organizations, incorporating intuitive human judgments with crisp. He indicated that strategy is a plan, a pattern, a position, a. In comparison with strategic planning, strategic management is the wider process that includes. A difficulty facing potential mcdm users is the wide range of different techniques that have been proposed, each with distinct advantages. A dynamic objectivesubjective structure for forest management. As there are a large number of available mcdm methods, varying complexity and possibly solutions, the decision maker also faces the problem of selecting the most suitable mcdm method among several feasible. Aug 08, 2017 kangas j, kangas a, leskinen p, pykalainen j. The purpose of this paper is to introduce the different methods and approaches used to enhance participation in information system is planning and requirements analysis. Request pdf mcdm methods in strategic planning of forestry on stateowned lands in finland. Ram, camelia, montibeller, gilberto and morton, alec 2011 extending the use of scenario planning and mcda for the evaluation of strategic options. Multiple criteria decision support methods in forest management.
An application of fuzzy numbers in quantitative strategic. Pdf outranking methods as tools in strategic natural resources. A fuzzy sequential model for realization of strategic. How to design and realize participation of stakeholders in. Scores were assigned to each criterion and subcriterion by. Readers will note considerable overlap among these elements as well as the synergy between qualitative and quantitative methodologies within each planning element. It is an outranking method, typical of the european or french mca school. Organizations and teams typically develop a concrete strategy for a financial year.
It can be general, sweeping and vague, but at least it tells you that you the strategic planning process 1. The forests in finland have been under intensive planning for decades. Two outranking methods, electre iii and promethee ii, commonly used as. Using different electre methods in strategic planning in. According to the literature,2 states and also many local governments essentially agree that strategic planning is a process of developing a longterm plan to guide an. The quantitative strategic planning matrix qspm is a useful tool to prioritize strategies at any level including corporate, business and functional. In order to solve such complex problems concerning energy planning, multi criteria decision making mcdm is proved to be one of the better tool for efficient energy planning. Application of multicriteria methods in natural resource. Mcdm methods in strategic planning of forestry on stateowned lands in. Jyrki kangas, annika kangas, pekka leskinen and jouni pykalainen, mcdm methods in strategic planning of forestry on state. Multicriteria decision analysis in natural resource. Martins b a department of natural resources and environmental sciences, university of illinois, urbana, il, usa. Mcda has remained largely an academic exercise with some exceptions involving the use of ahp. This paper, using a sample case study within an organization, shows how different versions of electre methods can be used in choosing.
943 54 907 1276 159 74 1489 1079 147 1446 1128 205 1174 347 1145 233 763 207 971 1024 449 384 1385 1348 1281 902 313 377 635 773 914 657 182 1115 680 1180 691 591 1459 1230 825 1008 1098 97 1253 1066 530